| Year |
Winner |
Runner-up |
3rd place |
4th place |
| 1991 |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
H Simpson Jnr (Wick Old Stagers) |
A G E Allan (Watsonians) |
J H Hind (Balerno & Currie) |
| 1992 |
C W C Ogle (EU Alumni) |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
W F Brown (Chobham) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
| 1993 |
W T Vaughan (Hawick) |
J H Hind (Balerno & Currie) |
J R Buchanan (Masonic, Edinburgh) |
E J Jones (Larkhall) |
| 1994 |
W F Brown (Chobham) |
H Simpson Jnr (Wick Old Stagers) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
Mrs G R Henderson (Bury) |
| 1995 |
J G O’Connell (Chobham) |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
T F Hodgson (Dumfries) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
| 1996 |
H Simpson Jnr (Wick Old Stagers) |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
W F Brown (Chobham) |
| 1997 |
W F Brown (Chobham) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
G J B Winch (EU Alumni) |
W G Gibbon (Balerno & Currie) |
| 1998 |
Miss S M Bell (EU Alumni) |
C G DeJonckheere (Dumfries) |
Mrs G R Henderson (Bury) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
| 1998 |
W F Brown (Chobham) |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
I Thomson (Watsonians) |
| 2000 |
M M Mutch (Watsonians) |
W T Vaughan (Selkirk) |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
Miss S M Bell (EU Alumni) |
| 2001 |
W F Brown (Chobham) |
R A Sellar (Watsonians) |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
E J Jones (Larkhall) |
| 2002 |
W T Vaughan (Selkirk) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
A S Bruce (Balerno & Currie) |
G A Rudd (Watsonians) |
| 2003 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
E J Jones (Larkhall) |
Ms S M Sharp (Huntly) |
A S Bruce (Balerno & Currie) |
| 2004 |
J C Dummer (Bury) |
T F Hodgson (Dumfries) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
M I Thomson (Watsonians) |
| 2005 |
M Sinclair (EU Alumni) |
W F Brown (Chobham) |
A S Bruce (Balerno & Currie) |
N B Baker (Watsonians) |
| 2006 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
M MacGill (Watsonians) |
M Sinclair (EU Alumni) |
Mrs S M Jackson (Watsonians) |
| 2007 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
H Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
J R Sinclair (Wick Old Stagers) |
I McAlpine (Watsonians) |
| 2008 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
M Sinclair (EU Alumni) |
T Hodgson (Dumfries) |
I Thomson (Watsonians) |
| 2009 |
M Sinclair (EU Alumni) |
N B Baker (Watsonians) |
W T Vaughan (Selkirk) |
G Thorn (Sunderland) |
| 2010 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
J R Brown (Watsonians) |
M Sinclair (EU Alumni) |
T Kidner (Bon Accord) |
| 2011 |
A S Bruce (Balerno & Currie) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
T F Hodgson (Dumfries) |
R G Spence (Orkney) |
| 2012 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
J A Henderson (Watten) |
H Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
Ms H Doyle (Wigan) |
| 2013 |
A S Bruce (Balerno & Currie) |
G Thorn (Sunderland) |
M MacGill (Watsonians) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
| 2014 |
J R Sinclair (Wick Old Stagers) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
A S Bruce (Balerno & Currie) |
R R Simpson (Greenock) |
| 2015 |
K Greenaway (St Andrews) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
Ms H Doyle (Wigan) |
W T Vaughan (Selkirk) |
| 2016 |
R R Simpson (Greenock) |
K Greenaway (St Andrews) |
H Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
D Caughey (Watsonians) |
| 2017 |
J G Shedden (Dumfries) |
K Greenaway (St Andrews) |
P Duxbury (Chobham) |
R R Simpson (Greenock) |
| 2018 |
H Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
A S Bruce (Balerno & Currie) |
D Caughey (Watsonians) |
R R Simpson (Greenock) |
| 2019 |
R R Simpson (Greenock) |
D Strachan (Dunfermline) |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
A Fowler (Wimbledon Park) |
| 2020 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
H Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
R B Campbell (Halkirk) |
M Lowe (Wigan) |
| 2021 |
A Anderson (Hawick) |
A Gordon (Dulnainbridge) |
R Thomson (Watsonians) |
J McCarthy (Greenock) |
| 2022 |
H Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
A Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
J Godsell (Dunfermline) |
D Thorn (Sunderland) |
| 2023 |
A J Horne (Balerno & Currie) |
R B Campbell (Halkirk) |
A Dove (Watsonians) |
P Duxbury (Chobham) |
| 2024 |
D Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
H Simpson (Wick Old Stagers) |
R B Campbell (Halkirk) |
D Bremner (Watten) |
| 2025 |
A Gordon (Dulnainbridge) |
L Thomson (Huntly) |
C Stirling (Dunfermline) |
R Gascoyne (Felton) |